A few years ago, I purchased a Panasonic PV-DV851 camcorder which, in its day, was absolutely a killer camera (if this is any hint, it sold new for $1599!). I bought it when it was getting phased out on clearance, so I paid a fraction of that price. Even though it was getting phased out in lieu of better models, it still had all the bells and whistles you wanted on a camcorder: a great LCD, digital video, even still photos which could be saved on a memory card! Naturally, it then had FireWire for copying the video to the Mac to do your video editing in iMovie.
Yawn. All of that is old hat now. This camcorder is starting to feel long in the tooth. The image seems a bit grainy now, having to use a tape feels so turn-of-the-century, and it doesn’t even support widescreen video!
Fast-forward to this past week. I went to Best Buy on Monday with a 12% off coupon in my hand, on top of a general camcorder sale they were having, with full intentions to buy a camcorder before I go on vacation. I already had the camcorder picked out; I was going to buy the Panasonic PV-GS500, because MacWorld gave it a glowing review. It was perfect: I already like Panasonic; it supports SD cards, which is my preferred memory card format; it uses MiniDV and FireWire, guaranteeing smooth operation with my Mac; it supports widescreen video; and most importantly, it is a 3 CCD camcorder, instead of using a single CCD like most.
I had been in stores playing with it a few times in the past. This time, I stood in front of it ready to make the purchase. As we stared each other down, I came to a realization. I don’t really like this camcorder! Its bulkiness is disturbing, its appearance is worse, and the UI, although not horrendous, is very boring. Frankly, I’m disappointed that a Mac magazine, written by people who appreciate the importance of these kinds of things, rate this camcorder as one of their “Best Picks”.
And then I started browsing around. I let my eyes incorrigibly wander over to the hard drive camcorders, and before I knew it, I was looking at the camcorders with all the features I’ve been wanting…with the price tag I don’t.
Let me introduce to you what a camcorder should be like nowadays, and it is almost exemplified in the Sony HDR-SR1. This camcorder was gorgeous. I couldn’t put it down. Warning: If you have a problem putting down cool tech toys, it might be best for you to just not even pick up this camcorder in the first place!
For starters, it features a beautiful widescreen 3.5″ LCD. It’s a good thing too, because it can show off the amazing 1080i video you’ll be recording using Sony’s AVCHD format. The great picture is achieved by using a CMOS sensor versus a CCD, which is not only arguably better quality, but also consumes less power. The quality is so good that, despite being a video sensor, this camcorder can still take 4MP still images. Oh, and while you’re enjoying that notably high-quality picture, you might try navigating through the great UI, which has been improved over Sony past models, and like its past models, the UI is a touch-screen interface on the 3.5″ LCD. A screen large enough to make touch-screen really nice, with (finally) a pretty UI that is a joy to use. To top things off, it features a 30GB hard drive supporting 10 hours of video in LP mode, and 5.1 surround sound audio recording.
A hard drive camcorder that records high-definition widescreen video with surround sound and a touch-screen 3.5″ LCD. I like. I like very much. Look. I’m drooling.
After haggling with the salesperson for a deal (only the demo model was left, even though it was just put on the floor that day), on top of an existing sale price, and with a 12% off coupon, I bought this beauty and still paid too much money.
Then I brought it home and discovered some serious cons. This list is a lot shorter than the list of pros, and yet they were still deal-breakers for me. The Sony HDR-SR1 doesn’t have a FireWire port (only USB 2.0), meaning iMovie on my Mac doesn’t want to import its video. And it wouldn’t be able to import it anyway, because iMovie and Final Cut Pro do not support AVCHD at this time. Frankly, there may not be any video editing software that currently supports AVCHD except the software that Sony includes with the camcorder, because it is a very new format.
These cons aren’t really faults in the camcorder itself; nevertheless, I can’t buy a camcorder that I can’t use with my Mac. I returned it the same night. It is rumored that Apple will announce AVCHD support in January at the MacWorld Expo, but until that happens, I will keep my poor little PV-DV851.
In the meantime, I will keep on the lookout. I await Apple’s support for AVCHD in iMovie and Final Cut Pro. And when I do buy a camcorder, I hope it can have all of the bold features listed above.